Examine the presentation of women in ‘AHWOSG’
Overview, quotes and plan
Throughout
the memoir, Eggers uses a range of linguistic features, terminology and
carefully picked words to express his feelings about women. From this, we also
understand what ‘Dave’ is like as a person, how he treats others and most
importantly his views on women. I believe Eggers deliberately portrays women
the way he does in this memoir to reflect his personality which in times can be
seen as controversial and ultimately sexist which is surprising considering his
mother’s circumstances. I notice at the beginning of the memoir Dave is very
careful with how he talks and acts with his mother however this respect is lost
later on in the memoir when Dave is left to live on his own and therefor finds
comfort in women.
Blue =
Terminology
Pink = Meaning
Page 8 – ‘I am holding
the nose’ declarative, short
sentence, dynamic verb, care, protectivness over mothers illness, respect, love
Page 11 – ‘Her skin is smooth, brown’ – Adverbs, short sentences, caesura to
emphasize its continuous and used through an asyndetic list, shows respect for his mother,
precious, caring, notices little details
Page 38 – ‘I expected someone so sweet and normal looking to
find me out soon enough’ complex,
expectation of others,
secrecy of Dave, unreliable author, description of woman
Page 57 – ‘I don’t want to be friends with these women
anyway’ Harshness,
unsocial, jealousy, anger
Page 60 – ‘There better be some very impressive nude women
down there’
Page 69 – ‘Busty women stop and stare’ alliteration, direct description of
expectations of women, focused on looks
Page 74 – ‘the woman was not wearing any rings’ automatic assuming, only
thinks about status and using the woman for a place to live, fantasy
Page 75 – ‘maybe she had a boyfriend…that secure look’
Page 98 – ‘I was
looking to score’ Dysphemism,
expects a relationship,
expects women to like him
Page 98 – ‘the mother and I will go upstairs and screw around
while the kids play outside’
Page 98 – ‘most of the women are old enough to have mothered
me’
Page 105 – ‘Kirsten and I are taking a break…meaning we
(ostensibly) date other people’
Page 106 – ‘eventually we will go home together, to her apartment’ fantasising,
hoping, has nights planned out, dreams of what he could be doing
Page 107 – ‘A bad person’ assuming every woman who doesn’t follow their rules or doesn’t
so a specific thing is a bad person
Page 112 – ‘I was ready to be horrified’ hyperbole, description of woman’s body
Essay Plan
Examine the presentation of women in ‘AHWOSG’
Points to make in the essay:
- Beginning of memoir Dave is caring and respectable of his mother and he illness
- Gets defensive and jealous when at football club with mothers, can’t relate and feels everyone judges
- Takes Toph to a nudist beach for personal satisfaction, for Dave’s own entertainment, exploits Toph to the world of sex
- All about sex and looking to score a woman for himself out of desperation for a home and to feel youthful, fantasies about them all living together
Introduction
Talk about
the theme of love and relationships, how it develops and mind set changes,
loses respect, mother isn’t there to control or guide him with making good
choices and keeping respect for women. Women are presented differently in every
stage of the memoir after Dave and Toph go through a new experience. Eg. Mother’s
death and moving house
Paragraph one
How the
mother gets treated, there is respect for the illness and mother’s needs. Dave
notices and comments on details of the mother’s appearance and actions. Here
Dave clearly respects women and loves his mother very much. Page 8 – ‘I am
holding the nose’ Page 11 – ‘Her skin is smooth, brown’ Relate back to theme of
women commenting on how so far he seems genuine and very caring towards women,
including his sisters.
Paragraph two
Meets the
mothers when watching Toph at football, isn’t what he expected, reality,
doesn’t want to seem like a parent like the other mothers. Doesn’t want to be
friends with them, wants to be in a relationship, can’t find anyone at the
places he expects to. Page 57 – ‘I
don’t want to be friends with these women anyway’ relate to theme of woman as
he doesn’t want to make friends, has high expectations of living on his own.
Doesn’t want to accept he’s playing a parent, wants to be young still and act
like a teenager. Decline in respect.
Paragraph three
Personal
satisfaction and selfishness is shown. Irresponsible for Toph. Goes to a nudist
beach and tries to reassure himself it’s for ‘educational purposes’ Expresses
the fact Dave is only concerned about appearance and sexual fantasy. Page 60 – ‘There
better be some very impressive nude women down there’ Page 69 – ‘Busty women
stop and stare’ stereotypical image of a woman. Own entertainment. Relates back
to theme as there’s no respect, expects woman to look how he wants, high
expectations, typical young male personality, bad role model for Toph.
Paragraph four
Relates to
the theme of ‘home’ also. Daves jumps too far ahead, unrealistic in finding a
partner to live with. Desperation to find somewhere to live and have a happy
life. Feels he needs to find someone for Toph. Page 106 – ‘eventually we will go home
together, to her apartment’ Page 107 – ‘A bad person’ Page 112 – ‘I was ready
to be horrified’
Conclusion
How the
presentation of women changes throughout the memoir, loss of respect, bad influence
on Toph, wants to act young and not step up to a parent role, jealous of other
relationships, aims for sex.
Some very thoughful points and some good terminology being attached. Check caesura - it wasn't clear if it was accurate from the notes. The quote you used alliteration for has consonance in it - the st blend is also in the middle of "busty" and when consonant sounds are repeated but not just at the start of words it is consonance. What about Kirsten and Beth? Love the overview.
ReplyDelete